If we are to reach more than 1%-2% of the eligible patients who would benefit from treatment for morbid obesity and its related medical problems, then we need to take a different approach. We have about maximized how well we can do the surgical approach we now offer. It isn’t gaining in popularity among those who need it most. While we should not abandon the procedures that have been proven so effective, we should embrace new options for our patients.
It is certainly possible that the stigma of having surgery will resolve if a patient has an endoscopic procedure that is successful but only transiently. A more definitive operative procedure then may follow. Is that not ultimately better for that patient than having him or her never pursue a treatment for obesity? While this argument seems appropriate for the long-term overall patient good, the short-term increase in cost may make it a difficult sell to payers. But insurance companies are already doing their very best not to pay for highly medically effective and proven cost-effective bariatric surgery now. Only public pressure will force them to change – perhaps the public pressure of demand for endoscopic procedures.
Bariatric surgeons: It’s time to become bariatric endoscopists. If we want new patients, we need to adopt new treatments.
Dr. Schirmer is the Stephen H. Watts Professor of Surgery at the University of Virginia Health Sciences Center, Charlottesville.