Patient resistance/nonadherence
In 1920, Freud conceptualized the psychodynamic factors in patient resistance to treatment and theorized that many patients were unconsciously reluctant to give up their symptoms or were driven, for transference reasons, to resist the physician.7 This same concept may underlie patient resistance to pharmacotherapy. When symptoms constitute an important defense mechanism, patients are likely to resist medication effects until they have developed more mature defenses or more effective ways of coping.8 Even when patients do not resist symptom relief, they may still resist the physician’s choice of treatment due to negative transference. Such patients often negotiate the type of medication, dose, timing of the dose, and start date as a way of trying to “keep control” of a “doctor they don’t quite trust.”8 They may manage their own medication regimen by taking more or less than the prescribed dose. This resistance might lead to a “nocebo” effect in which a medication trial fails not because of its ineffectiveness but instead from the unconscious mind influencing the patient’s body to resist. Nonadherence to treatment may occur in patients who have attachment difficulties that make it difficult for them to trust anyone as a result of negative childhood experiences.9 Clinicians need to recognize the dynamics of power struggles, control, and trust. A warm, collaborative and cooperative stance is likely to be more beneficial than an authoritative and detached approach.10
The following 3 case examples illustrate how psychodynamic factors such as transference and countertransference can influence the therapeutic alliance, treatment decisions, and the outcomes of pharmacotherapy.
CASE 1
Mr. A, age 63, has posttraumatic stress disorder originating from his father’s death by a self-inflicted gunshot wound when Mr. A was 19, and later from the symbolic loss of his mother when she remarried. He reported vivid memories of his father sexually assaulting his mother when he was 6. This fostered a protective nature in him for his mother, as well as for his 3 younger siblings. After his father’s suicide, Mr. A had to take on a paternal role for his 3 siblings. He often feels he grew up too quickly, and resents this. He feels his mother betrayed him when she got remarried. Mr. A attempts suicide, is admitted to a local hospital, and then follows up at a university hospital outpatient psychiatry clinic.
At the clinic, Mr. A begins psychodynamic psychotherapy with a female resident physician. They establish a good rapport. Mr. A begins working through his past traumas and looks forward to his therapy sessions. The physician views this as positive transference, perhaps because her personality style and appearance are similar to that of Mr. A’s mother. She also often notes a positive countertransference during sessions; Mr. A seemingly reminds her of her father in personality and appearance. Perhaps due to this positive transference/positive countertransference dynamic, Mr. A feels comfortable with having his medication regimen simplified after years of unsuccessful medication trials and a course of electroconvulsive therapy. His regimen soon consists of only a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor and a glutamate modulator as an adjunct for anxiety. Psychotherapy sessions remain the mainstay of his treatment plan. Mr. A’s mood and anxiety improve significantly over a short time.
CASE 2
Ms. G, age 24, is admitted to a partial hospitalization program (PHP). Her diagnoses include seasonal affective disorder, anxiety, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD); she might have a genetic disposition to bipolar disorder. Ms. G recently had attempted suicide and was discharged from an inpatient unit. She is a middle child and was raised by emotionally and verbally abusive parents in a tumultuous household. Her father rarely kept a job for more than a few months, displayed rage, and lacked empathy. Ms. G feels unloved by her mother and says that her mother is emotionally unstable. Upon admission to the PHP, Ms. G is quick to question the credentials of every staff member she meets, and suggests the abuse and lack of trust she had experienced during her formative years have made her aggressive and paranoid.
Continue to: Since her teens...