Reengineering Physician Onboarding
In 2019, our department developed a multipronged approach to physician onboarding, which is already paying dividends in easing acculturation and fostering team cohesion. The department tapped its Center for Primary Care Innovation and Transformation (PCIT) to direct this effort, based on its expertise in practice transformation, clinical transformation and adaptations, and workflow efficiency through process and quality improvement. The PCIT team provides support to the department and the entire health system focused on technology and innovation, health equity, and health care efficiency.6 They applied many of the tools used in the Clinical Transformation in Technology approach to lead this initiative.7
The PCIT team began identifying key stakeholders (department, clinical and ambulatory leadership, clinicians and clinical staff, community partners, human resources, and resident physicians), and then engaging those individuals in dialogue surrounding orientation needs. During scheduled in-person and virtual work sessions, stakeholders were asked to provide input on pain points for new physicians and clinic leadership and were then empowered to create an onboarding program. Applying health care quality improvement techniques, we leveraged workflow mapping, current and future state planning, and goal setting, led by the skilled process improvement and clinical transformation specialists. We coordinated a multidisciplinary process improvement team that included clinic administrators, medical directors, human resources, administrative staff, ambulatory and resident leadership, clinical leadership, and recruitment liaisons. This diverse group of leadership and staff was brought together to address these critical identified gaps and weaknesses in new physician onboarding.
Through a series of learning sessions, the workgroup provided input that was used to form an itemized physician onboarding schedule, which was then leveraged to develop Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) cycles, collecting feedback in real time. Some issues that seem small can cause major distress for new physicians. For example, in our inaugural orientation implementation, a physician provided feedback that they wanted to obtain information on setting up their work email on their personal devices and was having considerable trouble figuring out how to do so. This particular topic was not initially included in the first iteration of the Department’s orientation program. We rapidly sought out different ways to embed that into the onboarding experience. The first PDSA involved integrating the university information technology team (IT) into the process but was not successful because it required extra work for the new physician and reliance on the IT schedule. The next attempt was to have IT train a department staff member, but again, this still required that the physician find time to connect with that staff member. Finally, we decided to obtain a useful tip sheet that clearly outlined the process and could be included in orientation materials. This gave the new physicians control over how and when they would work on this issue. Based on these learnings, this was incorporated as a standing agenda item and resource for incoming physicians.
Essential Elements of Effective Onboarding
The new physician onboarding program consists of 5 key elements: (1) 2-week acclimation period; (2) peer learning and connection; (3) training before beginning patient care; (4) standardization, transparency, and accountability in all processes; (5) ongoing feedback for continued program improvement with individual support (Figure).
The program begins with a 2-week period of intentional investment in individual success, during which time no patients are scheduled. In week 1, we work with new hires to set expectations for performance, understand departmental norms, and introduce culture. Physicians meet formally and informally with department and institutional leadership, as well as attend team meetings and trainings that include a range of administrative and compliance requirements, such as quality standards and expectations, compliance, billing and coding specific to family medicine, EHR management, and institutionally mandated orientations. We are also adding implicit bias and antiracism training during this period, which are essential to creating a culture of unity and belonging.