2 analgesic calamities: Death by fentanyl patch …
AFTER A WEEK OF INCREASING BACK PAIN, which had begun to shoot down his right leg, a 37-year-old man went to the ED. He was examined and given prescriptions for pain killers, including acetaminophen and hydrocodone, and muscle relaxants and discharged with instructions to return in 3 days for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
While he was at the hospital for the MRI, the patient returned to the ED because he was still in pain and his acetaminophen-hydrocodone prescription was running out. The ED physician prescribed a 0.75-mg fentanyl transdermal patch and instructed the patient to put it on his chest.
Three days later, the patient filled the prescription and applied the patch. The following day, his girlfriend found him dead in bed. Postmortem toxicology results showed a blood fentanyl level of 9.85 ng/mL, markedly higher than the therapeutic level. Respiratory failure caused by fentanyl toxicity was cited as the cause of death.
PLAINTIFF’S CLAIM The ED physician prescribed an excessive dose of fentanyl.
THE DEFENSE A defective patch or misuse of the patch caused the patient’s death.
VERDICT $1.2 million Indiana verdict.
… and methadone
A 36-YEAR-OLD MAN started treatment with a pain specialist for pain arising from a back problem, for which he had taken pain medication previously. The pain specialist prescribed methadone, 360 10-mg tablets. The prescription limited the patient to 2 tablets every 4 hours for a maximum dosage of 12 tablets (120 mg) per day.
Three days after the patient filled the prescription, he was found dead. An autopsy determined the cause of death to be drug toxicity from methadone. At the time the patient died, the bottle of methadone tablets contained 342 tablets, indicating that he had taken only 18 tablets, well within the maximum dosage authorized by the prescription.
PLAINTIFF’S CLAIM The prescribed methadone dosage was excessive for a patient just beginning to use the drug. A proper initial dosage is between 2.5 and 10 mg every 8 to 12 hours for a maximum of 30 mg per day.
THE DEFENSE No information about the defense is available.
VERDICT Confidential Utah settlement.
COMMENT These 2 cases have a common thread. The effects of opioids are often idiosyncratic. A plan for careful monitoring and follow-up should be prepared at initiation of treatment and when escalating the dosage.